⚠️ IMPORTANT CONTEXT: This is an invited editorial (opinion piece, not peer-reviewed), not an empirical research study. Gregersen comments on findings from other studies, particularly Baharloo et al. (1998). This represents the scientific consensus of the late 1990s. Recent research (2020s) has challenged several of these assumptions, demonstrating greater trainability in adults.
🧬 Editorial Overview
In this invited editorial for the American Journal of Human Genetics, Peter K. Gregersen discusses the genetic and environmental influences on absolute pitch (AP), the rare ability to identify musical notes without a reference tone. Gregersen comments on emerging research from the 1990s, particularly the work of Baharloo et al. (1998), which surveyed 612 professional musicians. Key points discussed include:
- Genetic Component: Data from family studies suggest a relative risk to siblings (λs) of approximately 7.5-20, indicating hereditary factors. Twin data (3 identical pairs concordant, 1 fraternal pair discordant) support genetic influence.
- Early Training Impact: Musicians with AP typically began training before age 6, supporting the critical period hypothesis. However, Gregersen notes the difficulty in separating genetic predisposition from environmental triggers.
- Neurological Associations: The editorial mentions anecdotal links between AP and certain conditions such as autism and Williams syndrome. Gregersen reports that preliminary linkage tests with the Williams syndrome region (chromosome 7) yielded negative results.
- Prevalence Variability: Reported AP rates vary widely: 15% in Baharloo’s survey of professional musicians vs. 1-2% in other populations, possibly due to selection bias in conservatories.
Gregersen concludes that AP represents an “unusually discrete and quantifiable cognitive phenotype” ideal for studying the relationship between genetics, brain development, and cognition. He emphasizes that both genetic and environmental factors interact in complex ways, calling for more rigorous genetic mapping studies.
🔬 What Changed Since 1998
| 1998 Consensus | 2020s Research |
| Critical period <6 years likely necessary | Adults achieve 90% accuracy in 8 weeks (Wong 2025) |
| Strong genetic component (λs ~7.5-20) | Genetics influence but trainability was underestimated |
| AP prevalence ~1-15% (wide range) | With proper training, 177 adults developed some AP ability (Bongiovanni 2023) |
| Focus on hereditary factors | Focus on optimized training protocols and neuroplasticity |
💡 Historical Value: This editorial captures the state of AP research in the late 1990s, when the field emphasized genetic determinism and childhood critical periods. It provides valuable context for understanding how dramatically the field has evolved with recent discoveries about adult learning potential.
📄 Citation
Gregersen, P.K. (1998). Instant Recognition: The Genetics of Pitch Perception [Invited Editorial]. The American Journal of Human Genetics, 62:221-223.
Note: This article represents the opinion of the author and has not been peer reviewed. Available at:
View Full Study.